Speaking out about an area that is home to me, please can I ask you to sign this petition and support conservation organisations trying to stop the development of an elephant riding and lion petting facility that is proposed for Kleinmond.
‘Elephant rides and zoos are outdated practices, yet a new one is marked to open in the Overstrand Kleinmond area. Please sign to help prevent this from happening. Plans have been approved and the facility is being promoted as a sanctuary, but it is not one. These animals are not saved, they are being exploited for financial gain. Kleinmond does not need an elephant riding facility or a facility where wild animals are housed in cages.
Elephant riding is no longer seen as an acceptable tourist activity.
Please now read this article by Conservation Action Trust about the proposed captive wildlife enterprise which will substantially compromise the animals’ welfare.
A new safari park near the small town of Kleinmond in the Western Cape may hold economic gains for its owners – but at what cost to the sensitive Overstrand environment or the elephants and other animals subjected to exploitation?
Craig Saunders, a shareholder of ELEPHANT VENTURES AFRICA CC, plans to house elephants and other wildlife in a 20ha electrified enclosure in a new tourist venture near Kleinmond in the Overberg. Saunders has three other elephant riding facilities at Hartbeespoort Dam, at Hazyview and The Crags near Plettenberg Bay.’
A new safari park near the small town of Kleinmond in the Western Cape may hold economic gains for its owners – but at what cost to the sensitive Overstrand environment or the elephants and other animals subjected to exploitation? A number of inconsistencies have emerged in the plans for the development of Lamloch Safari Park (LSP) which are open for public comment or objection until 15 April 2019.
Elephant Introduction approved
Cape Nature has approved the introduction of elephants by Craig Saunders, owner of Lamloch, despite denying a Public Access to Information Act (PAIA) application. Saunders states that “there won’t be elephant petting”. However, according to CapeNature, there will “be elephant/human contact sessions according to the official LSP Elephant Management Plan (EMP),” spokesperson Loren Pavitt confirmed.
A recent former employee of Saunders’ Plett branch, speaking on grounds of anonymity, says “When I started working at Plett, [Saunders] told me there would be no elephant back riding. However, the practice was offered openly to guests. The elephants are constantly subject to the human entertainment demand.”
The drive to end elephant back riding is gaining momentum worldwide as it relies on cruel and abusive training techniques to ‘break’ elephants into submission. Young elephants are often chained and beaten, as seen in video footage leaked to animal welfare organisation on the ‘training’ of the infamous Tuli elephants. Saunders bought 5 of these baby elephants. He refused to comment when questioned over whether any of these elephants are still in used in his facilities.
The abusive methods, says Michele Pickover of the EMS Foundation, continues out of sight of the public. “The industry uses a false narrative of ‘rescuing’ animals they exploit.”
Lack of transparency
According to NSPCA Wildlife Trade & Trafficking manager Karen Trendler, they are “appalled by the lack of transparency received from Cape Nature”. The NSPCA was told to apply for information regarding Saunders’ captive elephants through PAIA.
However, CapeNature had previously refused a PAIA request from EMS Foundation asking for the same details. Despite a 2017 meeting in which CapeNature director Ernst Baard stated that “non-governmental organisations could play an important role to assisting them in developing best practice methodology and guidelines aimed at optimising the captive management of elephants”.
Pickover was present at the 2017 meeting with Baard. She labels the approval of the EMP as ‘underhand’. “On the one hand CapeNature says they do not support wild animal interactions but on the othe,r the Western Cape has the largest numbers of elephants in captivity in the country.”
CapeNature claims they do “not to support, condone nor encourage such non-essential human/wildlife contact or interaction [as it is] highly irresponsible, undesirable and potentially dangerous.” Permits for interaction practices like the ones offered at Saunders’ Plett facilities are continually approved by the organisation, however.
The introduction of three captive lions is also on the planned for the facility. The basic assessment report includes an extensive chapter on the park’s captive lion project, including a description of the feeding regime for newborn cubs.
Saunders backtracked again when a question about these plans saying, “no lion will be introduced”. He offered no explanation for contradicting the publicly available Report.
Concerned organisations and locals fear that the impact of building on the site and introducing elephant to these sensitive environments has not been sufficiently studied. Hermanus-based biologist Sally Paulet says the Environmental Impact Assessments (EIA) hasn’t assessed the critical environmental issues sufficiently nor “mitigated against any potential negative effects.”
Lamloch Farm lies within a UNESCO-recognised Biosphere Reserve and is adjacent to a recent RAMSAR-accredited wetland protected area. “The property is situated between the Kleinmond estuary and the Bot estuary, as well as between the mountain and coast. It plays a significant role as a corridor, for the movement of wild animals as well as the iconic feral horse population that exists in the area.
“The construction of a fence suitable to keep introduced animals [such as elephants] into the property will disallow the movement of these animals between these areas. Not enough focus has been given to this impact,” Paulet says.
An ongoing petition calling on the Overstrand Municipality and CapeNature to deny the proposed Safari Park developments has reached over 20 000 signatures.
** This is a guest post by Environmental journalist Louzel Lombard Steyn for the Conservation Action Trust. Read my other shared posts by CAT here. For more information connect with Sally Dowling at email@example.com or through their website. Look out for other guest posts from the Conservation Action team as I put my support behind their unwavering efforts. Pics supplied by CAT.
Absolutely NO WAY!!!! I will put my name and energy into preventing this from,happening.
Thank you so much, Carol. It’s devastating, and I read that the poor elephants are coming 🙁 For me, the shock is that CapeNature gave approval. Let’s keep up the pressure.
Unbelievable! What can we do about it I wonder?
Even the vegetation is not suitable! No way, too many times elephants are abused in ‘sanctuaries’ – give them a life to roam free and enrich their natural environment
Completely agree. Thankfully it has been stopped for now.
Disgraceful to still allow these practices in 2020! I absolutely agree it has to be stopped!! I will be signing the petition.
Let the wild roam free where they belong…The Bush… Not in cages in a Zoo
We do not need this zoo. Because that’s what it is! Surely in this day and age people can understand the dreadful cruelty these animals are subjected to to be able to behave the way we want them to!